Has Anthony Stolarz been good enough for the Leafs?

Has Anthony Stolarz Been Good Enough for the Leafs?

The Toronto Maple Leafs have had a fluctuating start to the current season after winning their division last year. One of their greatest strengths in the previous season was their solid goaltending. To build on that, general manager Brad Treliving signed Anthony Stolarz to a four-year contract with a $3.75 million average annual value.

Coming off a year where he posted a .926 save percentage in 34 games, the signing looked promising. Yet as the new season unfolded, questions started emerging about his performance.

Defensive Struggles Affecting Results

Before analyzing Stolarz’s individual play, one thing must be made clear: the Leafs’ defense has not been good enough. The team’s structure and defensive lapses have left Stolarz facing more pressure than any goaltender should reasonably handle.

"Stolarz has faced the ninth most high danger shots out of any goalie in the league."

That volume of dangerous chances makes it no surprise the Leafs have allowed the seventh most goals in the NHL. Stolarz currently holds a .895 save percentage, which reflects both team-wide defensive issues and his own inconsistencies.

Statistical Overview

Compared to last season, more quality scoring opportunities seem to be beating Stolarz. His advanced metrics support that impression:

-0.85 goals saved above average (GSAA), ranking 43rd in the league.
.895 save percentage, down from .926 last season.

Although the numbers are less favorable, context matters. The defensive zone breakdowns and sheer number of high-danger attempts make it difficult for any goaltender to post elite results.

Final Thoughts

While Stolarz’s play hasn’t quite lived up to expectations yet, the defensive struggles surrounding him suggest that responsibility doesn’t rest solely on his shoulders. A stronger team effort will be crucial for both the Leafs’ and Stolarz’s rebound.

Author’s summary: Toronto’s defensive fragility has hampered Anthony Stolarz’s performance, making it hard to evaluate his true impact behind a struggling blue line.

Editor In Leaf — 2025-11-08